Something that always impressed me about the Beatles was the quality of their B-sides. I liked their value for money approach which after the Please Please Me included not repeating themselves elsewhere or taking the easier option of putting out an album track. There always seemed to be a strong product identity; albums were albums and singles were singles. Quality was high resulting in the plain fact that most of their B sides would have been a lot of other bands A sides. One of the great B’s was She’s A Woman. This is a top tune and a major part of their live set which is a testament to the strength of the work. I’m trying to imagine the bands of today having that kind of ethic – putting a so called b side into the live set! Ho hum! Most groups today might use acoustic versions of their hit songs, or worse, an instrumental version of the main track. Other offences include the use of the extended remix and in most cases it is just self indulgent rubbish full of its own self importance. That kind of easy way out attitude just doesn’t cut it for me. It’s short changing the buyer. The Beatles didn’t do that. There was always a strong tune on the flip. Don’t Let Me Down, Revolution, Yes It Is, Things We Said Today – all somehow B-sides? You know the phrase “B-Side” somehow gives the impression that it’s not as good. This tells you how strong their singles were when tunes like these were relegated to the less important side. Today, we live in an era where the single means nothing. In their day, the single was just that, it was a SINGLE product with two unique tracks on board. Then, somehow the single became a leader for the album from which it came – in other words – merely an advert for the album. Using it as a device, a hook to make you buy. Now of course, in this world of the download you can just buy the track you like and ignore the B-side. I’ve said it before, there is something lost about that kind of consumption. The Beatles sold singles and albums by the truck load BECAUSE of the strong song writing and originality of product. Who wouldn’t bet on some of those B sides becoming hits in their own right due to the download phenomenon? A single wasn’t just bought as a collectable, never to be opened or played. You know, it’s the “Oh, I don’t need to play this anyway, ‘cos I’ve got it on the main album anyway” attitude, which begs the question – WHY buy it? If only Mr McCartney’s people had thought how it used to be done in the Beatles period during the Press To Play campagn. That was the time which ended my need to buy all of the formats. One of the singles (“Press” I think?) had NINE different versions available. Unfair to the loyal collector(like me) that. Shelling out left, right and centre for basically the same tracks again and again. More like RIP OFF I’d say now.
So, candidate for the best EVER b side? What do you think? I’d love to hear your thoughts – feel free to drop me a line on the subject.
My own favourite? Surely it must go to I am The Walrus! How that song ever got be a b side is inexplicable to me.
What was that about the quality of Beatles B sides?
Sunday, 8 June 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
7 comments:
Great blog, thank you. Best b-side IMHO, would have to be "You Know My Name" mainly becase of the humour in it. It's so original, creative, unexpected, and Pythonesque. And it came out at just the right time, with grey skies covering the whole let it be project - although I know this track was cut as a joke, almost, as early as 1967.
Loved your blog. My favourite Beatles B-side would have to be either Revolution or Old Brown Shoe. . . . or maybe its You Can't Do That, I'm Down and The Inner Light??? See! I think your point is made.
I so hear what you're saying about b-sides, but...I don't think "I Am The Walrus" supports your argument all that well, since it was really from the yet-to-be-released MAGICAL MYSTERY TOUR EP (LP in the U.S.). "I Am The Walrus" was likely chosen as the flip of "Hello Goodbye" because (1) the well was running a bit dry original material-wise towards the end of '67 and (2) it was the only John song available (George hadn't been given a b-side yet).
My personal fave for b-side would have to be "Don't Let Me Down." Now technically, it's not a real b-side either (it was cut during the GET BACK/LET IT BE sessions but selected to be on the single much later). Still, who knew that at the time? Not me, that's for sure!
thanks folks for all the comments so far! I hear what you're saying and I'm with you jeremyboob on Walrus. However, bear in mind that here in the UK, Hello Goodbye/I Am The Walrus was released on the 24th November 1967 as a single first. Then re-released as part the of Magical Mystery Tour soundtrack double EP set on 8 December, 1967. The repeat was on the EP and not the original single. So, it's a kind of yes and no situation with that particular track. The story is different in the States though as both the Hello Goodbye/Walrus single and MMT album were released by Capitol on November 27, 1967.
I agree with you about Don't Let Me Down. It's just a blindingly good song.
My favorite B-side is "Rain". I think it's even better than the A-side (which we all know is "Paperback Writer").
BTW, it was "No More Lonely Nights" which had eight different remixes. I spent a fortune on all of them.
If one would consider "Penny Lane" a 'b'-side (although I think, technically, it and "Strawberry Fields Forever" were paired as a double A-side), then it would win in my book. If not, I'd have to say "Rain" or "You Know My Name (Look Up The Number)." All three of these tracks respresent a tremendous artistic effort all around for songs destined to be flip-sides.
I agree with the last two posts about "Rain." IMHO, a most excellent B-side. In the 90s I saw the concert " A Walk Down Abbey Road" featuring Todd Rundgren, and Todd and his A-list bandmates included "Rain" on their set list. What a thrill! It's not a Beatles song that you usually hear covered, anywhere. I also highly rate "Revolution," with the up-tempo version on the single, IMO, superior to the bluesy version on the White Album.
Post a Comment